New Zealand Case Law: Decisions & Judgments | LexChat

New Zealand Case Law

Measure of damages (remediation vs diminution)
  • 11 Mar 2010

    T & T DRAINAGE LTD V RENNELL & ANOR HC AK CIV-2009-404-001506

    Citation
    openlaw-deeccd37_2df1_4e14_9145_7ffc3dd4c6e8.pdf
    Court
    High Court

    The Court held that the Rennells could recover personally because Mr Rennell acted as agent for undisclosed principals (the trustees) and retained personal liability; T & T breached an implied contractual and tortious duty by failing to take reasonable care (including failing to warn about winter risks) causing stone contamination and topsoil loss; remediation was a reasonable measure of loss given the property's specialised equestrian use so remediation costs were recoverable subject to quantified deductions for items of betterment and pre-existing contamination, and a 10% reduction for the…

    • Undisclosed principal/agency
    • Implied contractual duty of care
    • Director personal liability / assumption of responsibility
    • Measure of damages (remediation vs diminution)
    • Betterment
    • Contributory negligence