New Zealand Case Law: Decisions & Judgments | LexChat

New Zealand Case Law

Strike-out for no reasonable cause of action / improper joinder
  • 29 Sept 2009

    WATSON & SON LIMITED V ACTIVE MANUKA HONEY ASSOCIATION INCORPORATED AND ORS HC HAM CIV 2008-419-1495

    Citation
    openlaw-461e512e_ef0f_4a36_a2f3_41b56ec70290.pdf
    Court
    High Court

    The Court struck out Comvita New Zealand Ltd because the Amended Statement of Claim failed to plead sufficient primary facts to establish that Comvita UK acted as agent of Comvita NZ; the agency allegation was conclusory and therefore no tenable cause of action against Comvita NZ was disclosed. The strike-out was ordered on the ground of no reasonable cause of action.

    • Section 27 commerce act 1986 (anti-competitive arrangements)
    • Unlawful interference with contractual relations
    • Agency and attribution between corporate group members
    • Strike-out for no reasonable cause of action / improper joinder
    • Statutory demand / companies act s290
    • Fair trading act 1986 s9