New Zealand Case Law: Decisions & Judgments | LexChat

New Zealand Case Law

Court discretion and fairness
  • 29 Aug 2011

    TISCH & ORS V BODY CORPORATE NO 318596 COA CA359/2010

    Citation
    COA CA359/2010
    Court
    Court of Appeal

    The Court of Appeal upheld the High Court: s48 must be exercised with regard to the Act and body corporate rules; a court may not, as a general rule, make a scheme that requires owners to pay for other owners' private property (balconies) unless necessary and fair; the proposed scheme was an unwarranted departure from the Act and rules and was not fair and equitable, so the appeal is dismissed.

    • Scheme under s48 unit titles act
    • Leaky building remediation
    • Apportionment of repair costs
    • Interpretation of body corporate rules
    • Court discretion and fairness