New Zealand Case Law: Decisions & Judgments | LexChat

New Zealand Case Law

Market value vs actual cost
  • 6 May 2020

    ELECTRIX LIMITED v THE FLETCHER CONSTRUCTION COMPANY LIMITED NO 2 [2020] NZHC 918

    Citation
    [2020] NZHC 918
    Court
    High Court

    No binding contract was formed: the parties never objectively intended to be immediately bound on essential terms and LOIs did not evidence such intent; Electrix provided services at Fletcher's request which Fletcher accepted with knowledge Electrix expected payment; accordingly Electrix succeeds on a non-contractual quantum meruit and is entitled to recover the reasonable cost of the services actually provided (market-related cost plus margin), assessed at $7,473,207 (GST excl) with simple interest at 5% p.a.; Fletcher Construction's counterclaims under the Fair Trading Act and for negligent…

    • Existence of contract
    • Letters of intent
    • Early contractor involvement
    • Amount deserved
    • Valuation of services
    • Market value vs actual cost