Mashinini v Road Accident Fund (14849/13) [2014] ZAGPPHC 726 (19 September 2014)
Court
North Gauteng High Court, Pretoria
Case number
14849/13
Judge
BAM
The court held that section 36 of the Compensation Occupational Injuries and Diseases Act requires the full amount awarded by the Compensation Commissioner to be deducted from the damages payable by the Road Accident Fund, not merely the amount already paid. The plaintiff's argument that only the paid portion should be deducted was rejected, as the statutory provision and the precedent in RAF v Maphiri make it clear that the entire award must be considered. The plaintiff's difficulties with the adequacy or administration of the monthly payments are matters between the plaintiff and the Commis…
Source excerpt
Loss Of Support
Compensation For Dependants
Compensation Occupational Injuries And Diseases Act
Constantia Versekeringsmaatskappy Bpk. v Victor (470/84) [1985] ZASCA 138; [1986] 2 All SA 6 (A) (29 November 1985)
Court
Supreme Court of Appeal
Case number
470/84
Judges
Rabie, Joubert, Hoexter, Botha, Nicholas
The Supreme Court of Appeal held that the adoption of a child after the wrongful death of his natural parents does not extinguish or reduce the child's right to claim damages for loss of support. The maintenance obligation of the adoptive parent is a new legal duty, distinct from the right to compensation for the loss suffered due to the death of the natural parents. The analogy to a widow's remarriage is inappropriate, as adoption is not a direct consequence of the wrongful death and should not be considered a mitigating factor in the calculation of damages. The damages awarded for loss of s…