Hong Kong Case Law: Decisions & Judgments | LexChat

Topic

Access to common areas

Legal area

Court

18 May 2012

SILVER TRIUMPH HOLDINGS LTD v. GUARDIAN PROPERTY MANAGEMENT LTD

Citation

SILVER TRIUMPH HOLDINGS LTD v. GUARDIAN PROPERTY MANAGEMENT LTD
Court

Court of First Instance
Case number

HCMP566/2012

On proper construction the Owner's right of access under the DMC and the Manager's control rights coexist and are mutually subject; the Manager's blanket refusal to provide a duplicate key unlawfully and unreasonably interfered with the Owner's use and enjoyment of its premises. The intended appeal had no reasonable prospect of success and leave to appeal was refused.
20 Mar 2006

LET\'S GO INVESTMENTS LTD v. YEUNG SAU HING

Citation

LET\'S GO INVESTMENTS LTD v. YEUNG SAU HING
Court

Court of First Instance
Case number

HCMP54/2006

Leave to appeal was refused because the judge's factual findings, supported by expert evidence, were not plainly wrong and the defendant had no real prospect of success on appeal; the damages of $50,000 adequately compensated the security risk and remedial measures and were not shown to be manifestly inadequate.