8 Jun 2009
KOON WING YEE v. INSIDER DEALING TRIBUNAL AND ANOTHER
- Citation
- KOON WING YEE v. INSIDER DEALING TRIBUNAL AND ANOTHER
- Court
- Court of Appeal
- Case number
- CACV358/2005
The Court held that the IDT was not inherently or institutionally biased and its procedures (judge with lay members, SFC investigation, counsel for Tribunal) preserved independence and impartiality under Article 10; s31(1)(b) leave requirement for appeals on fact is a constitutional and proportionate filter and does not deny access to the Court of Final Appeal; the Tribunal's adverse factual findings (agency of Lam and tipping to Sonny Chan) were supported by the evidence and proper inferences and are therefore restored; s23(1)(a) disqualification orders need not name each company to be valid…