17 Dec 2012
HO KAR CHEE v. TAM KWONG MAN AND ANOTHER
- Citation
- HO KAR CHEE v. TAM KWONG MAN AND ANOTHER
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCPI439/2007
Master K Lo accepted the defendants' orthopaedic and psychiatric experts (Dr Danny Tsoi and Dr Singer) and the surveillance evidence over the plaintiff's accounts and some plaintiff-appointed opinions, holding the 2006 incident caused a minor right knee soft tissue sprain with minimal residual effect (1% orthopaedic impairment; psychiatric impairment negligible or 1% reducible to 0% with treatment), that the plaintiff's evidence of severity and high earnings was unreliable, and awarding total damages of HK$146,400.70 with specified interest and costs orders.