16 Aug 2024
THE INCORPORATED OWNERS OF GRENVILLE HOUSE v. KEEN JOY ENTERPRISES LTD
- Citation
- [2024] HKLdT 57
- Court
- Lands Tribunal
- Case number
- LDBM200/2020
Leave to appeal refused because the proposed grounds had no reasonable prospect of success: the Tribunal's factual finding that the existing fire alarms were in good working order was open on the totality of the evidence (audibility in living/dining areas, three annual FS certificates, manager's proposal and FSD non-action), Keen Joy introduced s.18(1)(c) of BMO and clause 9(b)(8) of DMC for the first time on appeal which was unfair and unarguable on the state of the evidence, compliance with relevant codes of practice can negative liability, and no public interest or other reason justified g…