Hong Kong Case Law: Decisions & Judgments | LexChat

Hong Kong Case Law

Consolidation and stay

  • 5 Feb 2010

    LEUNG PING YEUNG AND OTHERS v. JETOUR HOLIDAY LTD

    Citation
    LEUNG PING YEUNG AND OTHERS v. JETOUR HOLIDAY LTD
    Court
    Court of First Instance
    Case number
    HCPI707/2008

    The court refused the Defendant's application to adduce expert evidence on liability because there was no accident sketch, tyre marks or other forensic data and the proposed expert evidence was neither necessary nor sufficiently probative; the court allowed evidence on industry practice to be given by the Defendant's experienced Director of Operations by way of a 14‑day supplemental statement rather than a separate broker; refused all requests for further and better particulars; ordered a stay of HCPI 857/2008, HCPI 858/2008 and HCPI 933/2008 pending determination of HCPI 707/2008; refused an…

  • 5 Feb 2010

    CHEUNG SUK YUEN v. JETOUR HOLIDAY LTD

    Citation
    CHEUNG SUK YUEN v. JETOUR HOLIDAY LTD
    Court
    Court of First Instance
    Case number
    HCPI857/2008

    The Court refused the defendant's application for expert evidence on liability because no accident sketch, measurements or other probative material existed to make such expert evidence necessary or likely to be of assistance; allowed evidence on industry practice only by defendant's Director (Mr Chau) by supplemental statement within 14 days rather than an external broker; refused all requests for further and better particulars as unnecessary or premature; refused adjournment for service of third party proceedings outside jurisdiction; ordered HCPI 857/2008, HCPI 858/2008 and HCPI 933/2008 st…