9 Aug 2007
LUK KA MING t/a TIN MUK ENGINEERING CO v. YKK AP HONG KONG LTD
- Citation
- LUK KA MING t/a TIN MUK ENGINEERING CO v. YKK AP HONG KONG LTD
- Court
- District Court
- Case number
- DCCJ3516/2004
Plaintiff's claims for the outstanding balance and for variation payments were dismissed because the plaintiff failed to prove that the main contractor had paid the defendant (a prerequisite under the payment and retention clauses) and failed to substantiate the variation claim with proof that any extra payment received corresponded to the variation claim; defendant's counterclaims failed for lack of particulars and causation except for reimbursement of the employee compensation insurance premium which was proved and awarded.