4 Apr 2014
TUNG NGAR AIR CONDITION & STEEL HOLDINGS LTD v. SHING HIN CATERING GROUP LIMITED
- Citation
- TUNG NGAR AIR CONDITION & STEEL HOLDINGS LTD v. SHING HIN CATERING GROUP LIMITED
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCA1410/2009
The application was dismissed because the plaintiff failed to show prima facie relevance of the documents to the pleaded case (making the request a fishing exercise), the application was unreasonably delayed and departed from prior listing statements, and granting discovery at this late stage would likely derail scheduled trial dates; costs were awarded to the defendant and summarily assessed at $79,850 payable within 14 days.