16 Aug 2005
BRIAN ALFRED HALL v. SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE FOR : COMMISSIONER OF CORRECTIONAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT, COMMISSIONER OF POLICE AND COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS & EXCISE DEPARTMENT
- Citation
- BRIAN ALFRED HALL v. SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE FOR : COMMISSIONER OF CORRECTIONAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT, COMMISSIONER OF POLICE AND COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS & EXCISE DEPARTMENT
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCAL140/2004
Court dismissed judicial review challenges on medical treatment and tape seizure because prison medical staff acted professionally and lawfully within their discretion relying on consultant opinions and investigatory steps; seizure of tapes was rational pending verification and applicant was invited to supply evidence; however disciplinary proceedings were vitiated because the adjudicating officer refused to consider a requested CCTV recording and accepted a secret representation thereby causing material unfairness, and the decision to return the applicant to normal association was unreasonab…