13 May 2005
HO SHUK CHING PORTIA v. WONG MEI CHU AND OTHERS
- Citation
- HO SHUK CHING PORTIA v. WONG MEI CHU AND OTHERS
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCA1213/2003
The plaintiff failed to show the high degree of assurance of success necessary for a mandatory interlocutory order compelling delivery up of the 2nd defendant's documents; the relief sought is highly intrusive and would cause grave prejudice to the defendants, damages are an adequate remedy, and the balance of convenience favors refusal of the mandatory orders. Inspection of the 3rd defendant's documents is allowed by undertaking under Companies Ordinance s121 rather than by delivery up.