12 Jul 2018
FOK HING INTERNATIONAL CO LTD v. LIU HSIAO CHENG
- Citation
- [2018] HKCFI 1612
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCA97/2013
Applicant failed to establish prima facie relevance of the requested classes of documents to the issues in dispute; the AFS did not disclose the Trading JV or allow segregation of FHI's own business from the alleged JV business; the Summaries did not prima facie relate to the Trading JV; disclosure sought was wide and disproportionate contrary to Order 1A objectives; Class 7 documents were not shown to be in respondents' possession—therefore specific discovery refused and appeal dismissed.