23 Jan 2020
LAI NG NUI AND OTHERS v. FUNG TIN YAU
- Citation
- [2020] HKCFI 252
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCA2225/2016
The Court dismissed all three sets of appeals: (1) the 2078 strike out appeal was dismissed because the counterclaim alleging assumption of fiduciary duties disclosed a reasonable cause of action and was not plainly and obviously unsustainable; (2) the appeals against dismissal of the 2998-3000 O.14 summonses were dismissed because the respondent's defences (Withdrawal/Wyse Agreements and related estoppel/Duomatic arguments) raised triable issues and summary judgment/conditional leave to defend was inappropriate; and (3) the 133/136 derivative strike out appeals were dismissed because the res…