7 Sept 2011
CHAN NGAN BING v. FUNG YEUK HUNG
- Citation
- CHAN NGAN BING v. FUNG YEUK HUNG
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCA130/2009
Court found that Chan proved nuisance from the air-conditioner (Issue A) for about three months and from the flower bed (Issue B) continuing since March 2002; awarded Chan HK$5,000 and HK$55,000 respectively. Court found no proven source for the alleged utility-area seepage (Issue C) and no sufficient proof of excessive noise (Issue D) or of property damage (Issue E). The court found that elements of malicious falsehood were made out against Chan in relation to repeated false statements about seepage (Issue G/H) and assessed Fung's damages at HK$55,000 general and HK$2,000 special; netting th…