10 Dec 2008
IP SUK CHING v. LUK KAM HEUNG
- Citation
- IP SUK CHING v. LUK KAM HEUNG
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCA1215/2006
The court found the judgment debtor willfully failed to disclose requested documents and particulars (including liabilities secured on the Shatin property and particulars of transactions over HK$20,000) despite a year and a consent order; there was insufficient evidence to prove dispositions were made with the sole purpose of avoiding the judgment; the debtor was able to satisfy the judgment; consequently committal was appropriate for willful non‑disclosure and, concurrently, an instalment order was justified; imprisonment and instalment orders are not mutually exclusive.