8 Jul 2022
RE PAN SUTONG
- Citation
- [2022] HKCFI 2076
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCB6548/2021
The court held that the HCMP, CACV and HCSD determinations are binding by way of issue estoppel and Henderson abuse; the Company and Pan are precluded from re‑litigating the bona fide dispute and jurisdiction points; the Peng evidence and transcripts do not meet the narrow Arnold/Ladd v Marshall exceptions; the Debt of HK$8 billion remains unpaid and not bona fide disputed, thus the court made the usual winding up order against Silver Starlight Limited and the usual bankruptcy order against Pan Sutong; costs to be assessed ordinarily with certificate for two counsel and nisi costs order, but…