29 Apr 2009
HO YUEN KI WINNIE AND ANOTHER v. HO HUNG SUN STANLEY AND ANOTHER
- Citation
- HO YUEN KI WINNIE AND ANOTHER v. HO HUNG SUN STANLEY AND ANOTHER
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCA391/2006
The 1st defendant established a prima facie case for specific discovery of (a) the 1st plaintiff's medical records and documents mentioning impairment to reasoning/thinking/social intercourse from 4 February 2002 to present, and (b) documents relating to the 2nd plaintiff's specific activities/events particularised in the defendant's voluntary particulars; broader discovery (general accounts, all donations, unspecified activities) was refused as too wide and fishing; production application is premature.