16 Feb 2024
張靜嫦 對 尚悅管理有限公司
- Citation
- [2024] HKLdT 13
- Court
- Lands Tribunal
- Case number
- LDBM113/2020
Applicant's relief was dismissed because respondent had taken reasonable and contractually permitted steps (including commissioning a qualified plumber whose report found no ongoing defect), the contested management choices fell within the manager's discretion and reasonable options under the Deed (so court will not intervene), the clubhouse is a common area under the Deed and clause 39 applies, and clause 12(a) does not entitle owners to determine the manager's fee amount by resolution.