10 Aug 2009
CHAN AH KWONG v. YAN CHEUK LUN AND OTHERS
- Citation
- CHAN AH KWONG v. YAN CHEUK LUN AND OTHERS
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCPI287/2005
The plaintiff failed to prove that the 4th Defendant breached any implied term, was negligent, or breached statutory duty in a way that caused the injuries; the attack was not reasonably foreseeable given the character of the estate and the plaintiff failed to show that possession of a truncheon or other measures would have prevented or reduced the harm, therefore the claim against the 4th Defendant is dismissed.