1 Nov 2016
MAN ON SUM v. MAN PING HEI
- Citation
- MAN ON SUM v. MAN PING HEI
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCA352/2015
The summons for leave to appeal was dismissed because the proposed appeal had no reasonable prospect of success: the Master erred in ordering production of the tong's bank passbook and explanations because that converted an Order 43 application for an account into specific discovery/interrogatories; whether the defendant had already rendered an adequate account is a preliminary question to be tried at trial; accordingly leave to appeal was refused and costs were ordered to the defendant.