12 May 2023
CHEUK CHI WAI AND ANOTHER v. HSU MAN NAI AND OTHERS
- Citation
- [2023] HKDC 633
- Court
- District Court
- Case number
- DCCJ4864/2022
On the pleadings the pleaded facts established continuous nuisance and statutory breaches by the defendants with no defence filed; a mandatory injunction ordering removal of the four unlicensed dogs from House 49 is appropriate to protect the plaintiffs' quiet enjoyment, a perpetual ban would be too wide given Estate Rules permit one licensed dog, and plaintiffs are entitled to damages for loss of amenity and for inconvenience/discomfort, to be assessed; costs follow the event.