11 Jan 2013
YUI CHUNG YIN v. NG KIT SUM
- Citation
- YUI CHUNG YIN v. NG KIT SUM
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCA1826/2009
On the evidence the court preferred the defendant's contemporaneous invoices and account ledgers over the plaintiff's unsupported tables; the unit price included a HK$450 markup; the plaintiff had taken delivery of adaptors and was not entitled to a HK$130,000 cash rebate; defendant's claim for finance charge of HK$7,711.20 failed for lack of agreement; final accounting showed plaintiff owed defendant HK$730,147; defendant's insurance counterclaim for autopaid premiums succeeded (except contested finance charge).