8 Oct 2008
ARTHUR LOH KOK CHEONG AND ANOTHER v. APPEAL BOARD UNDER THE SMOKING (PUBLIC HEALTH) ORDINANCE AND ANOTHER
- Citation
- ARTHUR LOH KOK CHEONG AND ANOTHER v. APPEAL BOARD UNDER THE SMOKING (PUBLIC HEALTH) ORDINANCE AND ANOTHER
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCAL16/2008
The Appeal Board applied an incorrect and unduly narrow approach by focusing on discrete periods and types of food rather than assessing what each establishment held itself out to be doing as a whole; turnover evidence may be relevant but is not determinative; Appeal Board's reasons were inadequate, rendering its decisions unlawful and liable to be quashed and remitted for reconsideration.