16 Apr 1999
KAMSHAN HOLDINGS LTD. v. CHAN TUNG MAN
- Citation
- KAMSHAN HOLDINGS LTD. v. CHAN TUNG MAN
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCA7959/1997
Defendant breached Clause 4 only in failing to remove chattels (filing cabinets); many alterations were ameliorating and unactionable, but certain alterations to the Second Premises (conversion for hoisting, conversion of residential sanitary/kitchen facilities and related changes converting residential character) constituted voluntary waste requiring reinstatement; plaintiff entitled to fair estimated reinstatement and professional costs totaling HKD 80,650; claim for loss of rent disallowed; costs to follow the event subject to District Court scale with order nisi.