20 Jul 2015
WONG CHOW HOI SZE ELSIE v. CROWN WINE CELLARS LTD
- Citation
- WONG CHOW HOI SZE ELSIE v. CROWN WINE CELLARS LTD
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCA43/2014
The appeal was allowed because the defendant satisfied the court that it had a real or bona fide defence requiring trial: there were substantial and unresolved disputes of fact and law (title to the wine, allegations of transaction to defeat creditors and trustees' claims, validity and exercise of a lien, and responsibility for delay) making summary judgment inappropriate; thus the defendant was granted unconditional leave to defend and the matter must proceed to trial.