15 Sept 2017
CHUN YIP PLASTICS LTD AND ANOTHER v. YUNG YUI KWAI AND ANOTHER
- Citation
- CHUN YIP PLASTICS LTD AND ANOTHER v. YUNG YUI KWAI AND ANOTHER
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCA937/2013
The court dismissed the pre‑trial valuation applications because mandating an independent, potentially costly valuation against the respondents' objections was not justified where parties could conduct desktop valuations and where commercial judgment did not favour the order; the court refused the proposed amendments because the pleaded claims were, on their face, time‑barred and the petitioner had previously approved audited financial statements that disclosed the accounting treatment, undermining any claim of unfair prejudice requiring amendment.