27 Apr 2015
CHEER SIGNAL DEVELOPMENT LTD v. WONG SIU FAN AND OTHERS
- Citation
- CHEER SIGNAL DEVELOPMENT LTD v. WONG SIU FAN AND OTHERS<br>
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCA780/2015
The court was not satisfied on the evidence that the plaintiff's claim was proprietary; applying the ordinary Mareva/injunction approach and the Wharf principles, Chan (D4) failed to prove absence of other assets except to the extent of specific mortgage payments. The court allowed a limited variation: Chan permitted to pay mortgage HK$37,500 per month and a one‑off HK$120,000 insurance premium (paid directly to mortgagee and insurer), increased disclosure time to 28 days, continued the Mareva injunction until substantive hearing, and dismissed the defendants' applications for wider legal cos…