15 Sept 2017
YUNG YUI KWAI AND ANOTHER v. YUNG WOON KWAI AND OTHERS
- Citation
- YUNG YUI KWAI AND ANOTHER v. YUNG WOON KWAI AND OTHERS
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCMP2550/2015
The court dismissed the pre-trial valuation applications and refused leave to amend. A pre-trial valuation was not justified given the parties' positions, likely cost, and the realistic prospect that party-led desktop valuation and discovery are sufficient; the amendments were refused because the alleged mischaracterisations were, on the evidence, either time-barred or inconsistent with prior audited accounts approved by the petitioner, and there was no satisfactory basis to attribute unfairness to the AY Camp such that the pleaded matters could support an unfair prejudice remedy.