29 Jan 2007
GRAND PALM INTERNATIONAL LTD v. WIN SMART INTERNATIONAL DEVELOPMENT LTD
- Citation
- GRAND PALM INTERNATIONAL LTD v. WIN SMART INTERNATIONAL DEVELOPMENT LTD
- Court
- District Court
- Case number
- DCCJ3612/2005
Although the court found the defendant had effectively admitted the product's circuit design could be wrong or improper (short-circuit risk when the switch was held in an intermediate 'misuse' position) and that the disputed product sold to the plaintiff was the same described by the buyer's customer, the plaintiff failed to prove recoverable loss. The claimed damages were unparticularised, largely related to downstream parties and unsupported by documentary or expert evidence; causation and quantification were not established. Therefore the claim fails and is dismissed despite findings on de…