13 Feb 2014
CHINAPLUS WINES LTD v. NICHOLAS FREDERICK PEGNA AND OTHERS
- Citation
- CHINAPLUS WINES LTD v. NICHOLAS FREDERICK PEGNA AND OTHERS
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCA905/2011
Advance discovery for the requested iPhone contact details is granted only on condition that the plaintiff gives an express undertaking not to copy, use or disclose the documents other than for the purpose of HCA905/2011 because the defendants' articulated concern about potential ulterior use (including vague police involvement) made it just and equitable to require the undertaking; the application for circa 50,000 old emails (2000-2006) is premature and should proceed, if at all, by normal discovery procedure given issues of relevance, cost and necessity, therefore no order was made for thos…