3 Nov 2005
CARLOS MANUEL KWONG v. LO KAM WING AND OTHERS
- Citation
- CARLOS MANUEL KWONG v. LO KAM WING AND OTHERS
- Court
- Court of Appeal
- Case number
- CACV128/2005
The judge's order for discovery (limited to specified periods and by affidavit/specific documents) was justified because the plaintiff's overall financial position during the periods when positions remained open was material to whether trades were intended to be cash or margin; the Hang Seng Bank letter was an inadequate snapshot; discovery was necessary and not oppressive; paragraph (3) of the Deputy Judge's order was unnecessary and was set aside; otherwise the appeal was dismissed and costs awarded to the 2nd Defendant.