27 Apr 1998
TALENT WISE LTD. v. CHEUNG SHUI CHING
- Citation
- TALENT WISE LTD. v. CHEUNG SHUI CHING
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCA11309/1997
Summary judgment was inappropriate because the circumstances raised serious and non‑frivolous possibilities (including potential collusion and that the plaintiff controlled key facts) which warranted investigation at trial; Clause 27 does not necessarily operate on an unsubstantiated third‑party claim, so the defendant had an arguable case and the appeal must be allowed.