10 Oct 2023
RE PAN SUTONG
- Citation
- [2023] HKCFI 2620
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCB6548/2021
The court dismissed the appeal: on a broad macroscopic assessment BOC's proofs of debt established a prima facie case that the Debt existed as at the commencement of bankruptcy and Seashore failed to adduce admissible or specific evidence to sustain its objection; the rule 99L procedure is summary and not a vehicle to relitigate the substantive validity of guarantees or to determine the precise quantification of claims; additionally Deloitte candidates displayed an appearance of lack of independence and were not appropriate appointees; Seashore's challenge was an abuse of process and indemnit…