16 Aug 2005
BRIAN ALFRED HALL v. SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE FOR : COMMISSIONER OF CORRECTIONAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT, COMMISSIONER OF POLICE AND COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS & EXCISE DEPARTMENT
- Citation
- BRIAN ALFRED HALL v. SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE FOR : COMMISSIONER OF CORRECTIONAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT, COMMISSIONER OF POLICE AND COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS & EXCISE DEPARTMENT
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCAL84/2004
Medical challenge dismissed: prison medical staff acted professionally, relied on specialist advice and no unlawful failure to provide appropriate/adequate treatment established. Seizure of tapes lawful: discretion to control possession of tapes was reasonably exercised and applicant failed to justify religious character of items; loss resulted from applicant's conduct. Disciplinary proceedings vitiated: adjudicating officer refused to consider CCTV evidence and material unfairness occurred; penalties quashed; no remittal ordered. Decision to return applicant to normal association unlawful an…