7 Feb 2023
鄭惠芬 對 黃玉英
- Citation
- [2023] HKDC 171
- Court
- District Court
- Case number
- DCCJ6404/2019
The plaintiff’s claims fail because the pleaded and proven facts do not show that the forgery caused loss of authorised occupant status (the TPS terms and Housing Authority correspondence confirm she remained a recognised occupant), the plaintiff failed to prove refusal by the defendant to return belongings, key factual evidence by the plaintiff was unreliable, and several asserted losses or novel legal arguments were not properly pleaded and therefore cannot support relief; accordingly all claims dismissed and costs awarded to defendant.