24 Jan 2024
CHOI WAN SHEUNG NANCY v. CHOI SI MING DANNY
- Citation
- [2024] HKCFI 186
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCA2336/2013
The defendant's evidence that he purchased the sisters' shares in 2001 and that the sisters forfeited interests in 2007 was rejected as inconsistent and unreliable; the court held the PW Property beneficial interests follow contributions to the purchase price, awarding Nancy 72.2105% and other siblings proportional shares; defendant breached his executor duties in selling HH Property at undervalue and must pay Nancy 20% of the shortfall ($80,000); defendant's counterclaim and rent claim dismissed.