15 May 2019
LI KIN KEUNG v. YAT FAT LTD AND ANOTHER
- Citation
- [2019] HKCFI 1226
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCA341/2013
Judge accepted Li's evidence over Pu's: the Undertaking Letter and payment records supported Li's contract for Yat Fat and did not contain any concurrent obligation to transfer 50% of King Wong; handwriting experts and witness credibility showed the 2009 documents were not signed by Li so the exchange of the bearer share was ineffective and Li retained beneficial ownership of General-Lite; Pu's competing factual narratives lacked detail, documentary support and commercial logic; accordingly specific performance was ordered for the Yat Fat sale and Pu's counterclaim dismissed, with declaration…