31 May 2024
CHINA JIANXIN CREDIT SERVICES LTD v. CHINA WAH YAN HEALTHCARE LTD
- Citation
- [2024] HKCFI 1461
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCA274/2020
The pleaded representations were, on the evidence and in context, non-actionable statements of opinion and commercial judgment rather than false statements of fact; accordingly the fraudulent misrepresentation claim disclosed no reasonable cause of action and was rightly struck out, the dependent conspiracy claim failed, summary judgment for CJCS stands, and the proposed re-amendments were refused for delay and legal unsustainability; costs awarded to CJCS on an indemnity basis under Clause 13 with PRG and LSM to recover on standard party-party basis.