9 Jan 2002
CHEUNG YIU BUN t/a C & S v. HO KAI CHEONG SAMSON
- Citation
- CHEUNG YIU BUN t/a C & S v. HO KAI CHEONG SAMSON
- Court
- District Court
- Case number
- DCCJ46/2001
The plea of non est factum failed because the defendant did not prove a radical mistake as to the document's nature or that he lacked understanding when signing; psychiatric evidence indicated onset after the transaction and the psychiatrist opined the defendant probably knew what he was doing though may have lacked good judgment; combined with consistent commercial dealings and corroborating documents, the court found the goods were received and the defendant liable for HK$108,438; the counterclaim alleging transfer of Michael Jordan cards was unsupported and dismissed.