27 Mar 2007
TUNG TAT ENGINEERING LTD v. WING KEY CONSTRUCTION CO LTD
- Citation
- TUNG TAT ENGINEERING LTD v. WING KEY CONSTRUCTION CO LTD
- Court
- District Court
- Case number
- DCCJ4114/2004
The court accepted the Plaintiff's contemporaneous payment records and signed payment notices over the Defendant's assertion of an extra HKD 70,000 payment; the court held the subcontract obligated the Plaintiff to clear site waste per contract terms and accepted specific deductions for waste disposal and guard‑rail repair as recorded, accepted that the Plaintiff carried out levelling work and rejected the Defendant's assertion the 2nd contract was performed for scrap value; the two payments in Aug–Sep 2000 were loans and are repayable. On that basis judgment was entered for the Plaintiff for…