Hong Kong Case Law: Decisions & Judgments | LexChat

Topic

Delineation of parking spaces

Legal area

Court

20 Apr 2026

CHAN FONG KIT v. THE INCORPORATED OWNERS OF KIN WING INDUSTRIAL BUILDING AND ANOTHER

Citation

[2026] HKDC 494
Court

District Court
Case number

DCCJ6528/2020

Plaintiff failed to prove intentional or persistent trespass or obstruction by SNC or that the IO breached its DMC/BMO duties; snapshot photographs and videos showed momentary crossings or loading/unloading in a constrained common area managed by IO security, which fell within permissible management conduct and de minimis doctrine; delineation and UBW issues were not live or resolved, therefore injunctive reliefs and damages were not justified and both claims were dismissed.
20 Apr 2026

CHAN FONG KIT v. SZE NGAN CHAI FROZEN MEAT LTD

Citation

[2026] HKDC 494
Court

District Court
Case number

DCCJ607/2019

Plaintiff failed to prove intentional or persistent trespass or obstruction by SNC; observed instances were temporary, often directed by IO security in a congested approved common area and fall within de minimis interference; IO acted within its DMC and statutory powers in managing loading/unloading and requiring measures (eg leaving keys) and did not breach duties. Consequently all claims (declarations, injunctions, damages) were dismissed and costs awarded to defendants.