31 May 2000
YIP LAI PING PORTIA v. DAH SING FINANCE LTD
- Citation
- YIP LAI PING PORTIA v. DAH SING FINANCE LTD
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCA15838/1999
O.14A was inapplicable because its statutory condition that the question, whichever way decided, must finally dispose of the claim was not satisfied: a negative answer would not finally determine the plaintiff's claim and there are disputed facts (including allegations of forgery and requests regarding the mark) and inadmissible hearsay in affidavits which require resolution at trial; hence the Master was right to refuse the O.14A application and the appeal is dismissed.