21 Sept 2012
LAU, WILLIAM JOHN v. WAN YUK LIN, ALISON AND OTHERS
- Citation
- LAU, WILLIAM JOHN v. WAN YUK LIN, ALISON AND OTHERS
- Court
- Court of Appeal
- Case number
- CACV196/2011
The appeal is dismissed because the trial judge was entitled to accept the contemporaneous company records and conclude the payments were consultancy fees rather than enforced contractual 'returns of investment', the plaintiff failed to plead or prove consideration or an enforceable agreement on the balance of probabilities, and the counterclaim was established by the company's books and a signed confirmation of balance.