27 Apr 2011
CHAN CHI SHING v. 陳觀華
- Citation
- CHAN CHI SHING v. 陳觀華
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCAL9/2011
The Revising Officer's decision dated 17 September 2010 is quashed because uncontroverted contemporaneous genealogical evidence (Lo Wai, Ha Wai and Wan Lok genealogies) established that KW Chan and the 116 People could not be male-line descendants required by VREO and the Revising Officer failed to take those relevant materials into account, producing a material error of fact and irrational decision; accordingly KW Chan was not duly elected and the inclusion of the 116 People in the final register constituted a material irregularity.