16 Jan 2014
MAK WAI YIM AND ANOTHER v. TAM SIU LING AND ANOTHER
- Citation
- MAK WAI YIM AND ANOTHER v. TAM SIU LING AND ANOTHER
- Court
- District Court
- Case number
- DCCJ1428/2012
The court accepted the ponding test evidence (appearance of fluorescent yellow-green dye observed by QTC technicians and confirmed by plaintiffs' expert Mr Wong on 7 February 2013) as proving Unit 2A was the source of water seepage to Room 1D; there was insufficient evidence to show Unit 2A caused seepage to Room 1C; accordingly defendants liable for damage to Room 1D only and plaintiffs awarded damages, while injunction was refused because seepage had stopped and a lapse of time without recurrence made injunctive relief inappropriate.