7 Apr 2021
CHAU YUET CHING BRENDA v. CHAN BO MAN WILLIAM AND OTHERS
- Citation
- [2021] HKCFI 640
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCA652/2017
The August 2016 oral agreement was not a binding contract for want of certainty and was at best an agreement to agree; the MKU, SY and related construction claims are unsustainable on the pleaded facts, inconsistent and unsupported by performance or particulars and amount to an abuse of process; the Pink Diamond transfers were not shown to have been made with intent to defraud creditors nor were the claimants prejudiced; accordingly the pleaded paragraphs 80, 82(d), 82(e) and 83 and related prayers are struck out, the counterclaim against Pink Diamond is dismissed and the HK$24,000,000 paid i…