30 Oct 2009
MAGENTA & CO LTD AND ANOTHER v. KOO YUNG SHOU
- Citation
- MAGENTA & CO LTD AND ANOTHER v. KOO YUNG SHOU
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCA2047/2008
The appeal was allowed because the plaintiffs failed to establish a good arguable case that the oral Agreement was between the 1st and 2nd plaintiffs and the defendant given contemporaneous documents indicating the parties were Yung or his corporate entities and the defendant or his entities; further the plaintiffs failed to disclose material emails on the ex parte application, and that non-disclosure required discharge of the ex parte order, so the interlocutory order granting leave was set aside and costs ordered accordingly.